All reviews on Hotel The Scotsman

Date: 26 November 2010
Name: Alexander McGillivray
Country:
Rate: 6,4/10
Comment: I had not used this hotel for three years. In that time, standards have slipped. A formerly excellent restaurant in the hotel has closed. The breakfast menu is limited and service (other than buffet) was slow (25 minutes and then we got poached instead of fried eggs). Long waits at the elevator. And so on. Overall, it's still OK but no longer offers the high quality guest experiences it once did. Overpriced now for what you get.

Date: 28 February 2010
Name: Anne-Marie MAISON
Country: France
Rate: 8,0/10
Comment: Accueil personnalisé, on se sent reconnu, j'y retournerai.

Date: 04 January 2010
Name: - -
Country: United States
Rate: 9,8/10
Comment: Everyone was lovely at the Scotsman and the location and room exceeded our expectations.

Date: 14 October 2009
Name: Graham Tracey
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 10,0/10
Comment: I stayed at this hotel as a special treat for my birthday - and a special treat it was! As soon as we arrived the service was top class. All the staff we came into contact with over the weekend couldn't be more helpful. The hotel, room and bathroom was spotless and lovely. MiniBar was well stocked and plenty options available. The spa/swimming pool area was lovely. Overall this is one of the best hotels I have stayed in - and in a beautful location in Edinburgh. I would definitely hope to visit again!

Date: 04 Septmber 2009
Name: - -
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 6,9/10
Comment: Service was very good, staff was helpful but rooms were very noisy, the size of the rooms were good but the views were terrible, one was facing a wall. I would recommend the hotel to a friend but would tell them to make sure they got a room on an upper floor.

Date: 28 August 2009
Name: - -
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 5,8/10
Comment: For a fairly expensive hotel the attention to detail and the service was a big disappointment

Date: 28 July 2009
Name: - -
Country: Germany
Rate: 7,3/10
Comment: Teppichböden im Hotel und Matratzen der Betten sind erneuerungswürdig.

Date: 23 July 2009
Name: Caroline Gilchrist
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 9,6/10
Comment: My favourite hotel in Scotland

Date: 29 March 2009
Name: - -
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 6,2/10
Comment: qualitiy of welcome based on the reception desk offical- the hotel porter was very good

Date: 24 February 2009
Name: Jones Jackie
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 10,0/10
Comment: Room was larger than expected, staff made us feel very and explained everything in detail. Breakfast was great as well as the restaurant staff. It would be helpful if public areas were identified - the lovely drawing room would have remained unseen had we not asked. A log fire would be nice in there as well. Would certainly go back - and the room rate was superb!

Date: 03 February 2009
Name: Isabella French
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 10,0/10
Comment: Had a most enjoyable stay at the Scotsman. Could not say a bad word about anything. From the moment we arrived we were greeeted with exceptionally charming, courteous and friendly staff. The room was very comfortable and breakfast was first class. Before arriving I had read some terrible reviews about the hotel and quite honestly I think these people must have been staying in another hotel. I will certainly have no hesitation in returning to the Scotsman or recommending to my friends. Thank you for a lovely stay and please extend our thanks to all staff.

Date: 31 January 2009
Name: - -
Country: Kuwait
Rate: 5,6/10
Comment: unfriendly and unattentive staff, especially at breakfast, dusty rooms although cleaned daily, charged horrendous amount for nibbles coming along with a bar drink, no greeting of guest when staff is crossing the guest during the day

Date: 30 January 2009
Name: Geraldine Kane
Country: Ireland
Rate: 10,0/10
Comment: We had a wonderful stay at the Scotsman and can't wait to get back.

Date: 08 January 2009
Name: Alexander Mackay
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 8,4/10
Comment: We were on the second floor and I was kept awake by passers by outside shouting and singing. Luckily my wife is a heavy sleeper.

Date: 04 December 2008
Name: Diane Gilmore
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 7,3/10
Comment: The wardrobe doors did not open fully to allow you to access the drawers because the bed was too close.

Date: 23 October 2008
Name: Helen Jacks
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 9,8/10
Comment: Had an absolutely wonderful stay for my boyfriend's birthday. I travel a lot as and can honestly say its one of the best hotels I have stayed in. Thank you

Date: 04 February 2012
Name: - -
Country:
Rate: 9,6/10

Date: 18 December 2011
Name: Catherine Allen
Country:
Rate: 10,0/10

Date: 23 October 2011
Name: - -
Country:
Rate: 9,8/10

Date: 16 August 2010
Name: - -
Country: France
Rate: 10,0/10

Date: 24 February 2010
Name: - -
Country: France
Rate: 10,0/10

Date: 02 January 2010
Name: Rainer Singer
Country: Germany
Rate: 8,9/10

Date: 26 November 2009
Name: - -
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 9,5/10

Date: 22 November 2009
Name: Ian Marsh
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 9,6/10

Date: 03 November 2009
Name: - -
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 9,3/10

Date: 11 August 2009
Name: - -
Country: France
Rate: 9,1/10

Date: 06 July 2009
Name: - -
Country: France
Rate: 8,9/10

Date: 22 April 2009
Name: - -
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 9,6/10

Date: 12 March 2009
Name: - -
Country: Netherlands
Rate: 9,1/10

Date: 04 March 2009
Name: Ella Palmer
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 9,6/10

Date: 27 October 2008
Name: - -
Country: United Kingdom
Rate: 9,6/10